The petition to end all petitions

Petition driveWhite House Website Draws Petition To End All Petitions


by Gene Demby, December 31, 2012

But Jarvis, a journalist, author, professor, media critic and Buzz Machine blogger, thinks the project is just enabling the attention-starved, especially in the aftermath of the Sandy Hook Elementary School mass shooting.

So naturally, he created his own petition on the site calling for an end to stunty, attention-seeking petitioning. “Petitioning government is a right as well as an opportunity for citizens to convene and for government to collaborate with them,” he wrote. “But this facility is becoming farcical. Indeed, this petition itself is merely link-bait, to demonstrate the point. If you’d like media to stop making fake stories out of fake petitions, sign below.”

I agree with Jarvis that We the People needs to go, but for different reasons.  I’ve seen a few of the White House responses (87 to date) to petitions that met the threshold.  As far as I can tell, We the People is worse than just another platform for the White House (regardless of administration) to generate these non-responses that miss the spirit of the petitions submitted.  The petition site also serves as a way to dilute what I think of as “one-click activism” by creating the appearance, not only that the White House is listening to us, but that by clicking our little hearts out on their site we are somehow meaningfully engaged in petitioning our government for redress of grievances.

In that sense, We the People is hardly the worst culprit.  For a good sample mugshot of a typical accomplice, many of us need only look in the mirror.  By all means, keep using petition sites that put pressure on Congress, as those appear to have some effect, but I seriously cannot imagine that any POTUS is going to change direction in any meaningful way because 25,000 (0.008% of the population) gives the White House the finger, clicking or not.

Calls, letters, and emails to Congress, that clearly and quickly state opposition to or support for an issue get tallied and, in sufficient numbers, may make a difference.  Social networking and GOTV efforts may make a difference.  If you are a card-carrying party member, getting involved in candidate selection at all levels of government may make a difference.  If you are politically independent, getting involved in recruiting and running suitable candidates may make a difference.

Clicking on We the People? Not so much.

Really want to make a difference? Here’s one way: get your hands dirty and beat some pavement.


Image credit: © Copyright Robin Stott and licensed for reuse under this Creative Commons Licence.

Nota Bene #124: I'm a Doctor, Not an Engineer

“I don’t believe in this fairy tale of staying together for ever. Ten years with somebody is enough.” Who said it? Continue reading

Nota Bene #122: OWStanding

“When I lie on the beach there naked, which I do sometimes, and I feel the wind coming over me and I see the stars up above and I am looking into this very deep, indescribable night, it is something that escapes my vocabulary to describe. Then I think: ‘God, I have no importance. Whatever I do or don’t do, or what anybody does, is not more important than the grains of sand that I am lying on, or the coconut that I am using for my pillow.'” Who said it? Continue reading

Zuckerberg is not your savior

After the Iranian elections, the Department of State formally asked Twitter to postpone scheduled maintenance so that Iranian activists could continue to tweet each other and the outside world. The internet will, apparently set you free. Now there’s some evidence that early communication between activists in Egypt was facilitated by Facebook and Twitter. The condemnation when Mubarak’s regime shut down the internet was much more muted. It didn’t stop the protests, suggesting that the internet is, at best, capable of being a tool of freedom but far from a necessity.

There are more than a few reasons why the meme of Facebook revolution is silly, not the least of which being that social networking moguls have neither declared nor proven that a fundamental aspect of their tools is to facilitate freedom. Continue reading

Nota Bene #102: Dancing Limbaughs

“What they really want to see is, they want you to chop your fucking arm off, hold up your arm, wave it around spewing blood, and believe me, if you did that, the crowd would go fucking ballistic. You only get four good shows like that, though. Four good shows, and then you’re just a torso and a head, trying to get one of your band mates to give you one last hurrah and chop your head off. Which they probably wouldn’t do, which would really be hell.” Who said it? Continue reading

Nota Bene #99: Heed the Peace Gnome

“You just pick up a chord, go twang, and you’ve got music.” Who said it? Continue reading

What Monckton's AFP event would have looked like if real Nazis had invaded instead of nonviolent climate activists

Last week, Lord Christopher Monckton accused a group of young climate activists who invaded an Americans for Prosperity (AFP) event where he was speaking of being “Hitler Youth” three times – twice caught on video (see these two posts from last week) and then at least twice on the Science and Public Policy Institute blog here and here (and he denied making the claim at an Associated Press event over the weekend). Clearly Monckton believes that the activists are behaving as the Nazis would.

Monckton is wrong. Temporarily taking over a meeting, chanting, and disturbing the organizers and invited speaker (Monckton) is not what the Nazis would have done. As someone who studied the history of Nazism and fascism in college, allow me to describe what would have happened during the meeting had it been invaded by the Nazis. Just a warning – I’m not going to go into gory detail, but I’m not going to sugar coat this either, so some of what I describe below is unpleasant. Continue reading

Lord Monckton labels climate activists "Hitler youth"

Americans for Prosperity (AFP) hosted a speech by Christopher Lord Monckton, a UK climate disruption denier, at Copenhagen yesterday. According to a report on the event at It’, there were only five attendees that weren’t AFP employees – until around 50 US youth climate activists showed up, took over the stage, and proceeded to hold up signs and chant “Real Americans for Prosperity are Americans for Clean Energy” from the stage behind Monckton, who continued his speech despite the disruption.

Until he drifted off message and said:

You are listening now to the shouts in the background of the Hitler youth.

Continue reading